Meet the Winners of the Just Like Us Awards

Quince Cashmere Crew

“With its sub-$60 price, Quince’s Cashmere Crewneck made the luxurious feeling of cashmere approachable for everyone,” says Executive Commerce Editor Tercius Bufete. “It’s really a shame that cashmere is best worn in colder weather, otherwise I’d wear it every day if I could.”

Abercrombie & Fitch Denim

“As a shopping writer, I always get asked about the best places to buy jeans and my answer is always Abercrombie!” says Commerce Writer Olivia Hanson. “In my opinion, the selection, customization options and overall high quality make it one of the best on the market. I know that no matter what jeans I like on the site, I can not only get them in my size, but also select my height as well, which is such a game-changer as a petite shopper. It reduces the stress of having to get anything tailored. Abercrombie also has curve options, which is another major bonus as someone who has some extra curves. It’s like I can literally pick out jeans perfectly tailored to my body and have them sent straight to my house. I wear my High Rise 90s Relaxed Jeans on repeat and am constantly getting people asking where I got them. They’re a can’t-live-without style!”

Cozy Earth Bamboo Pajama Set

“As a hot sleeper, this is the only pair of pajamas that keeps me cool and has actually held up through two years' worth of washes,” says Commerce Editor Madi Koetting. “I own a similar, much more affordable pair from a popular retailer. At first glance, the two are identical, but oh my goodness the cheaper pair has fallen apart in just one year of frequent wear and tear. These Cozy Earth Pajamas are worth every penny.”

Automet Oversized Sweatsuit

“If you ask my friends and family, they'll tell you I'm the queen of cozy,” Commerce Writer Jasmine Washington, says.” “With that said, this shopper-approved two-piece set is one of my go-to ensembles, especially when I'm traveling. The sweatshirt features a front pocket for me to store my wallet and boarding pass and a hood to keep me warm on chilly airplanes. Plus the sweatpants are ultra-cozy and look great paired with everything from cozy sneakers to animal-print clogs.”

Hill House Replica Luxury Handbag The Ellie Nap Dress

Commerce editor Samantha Sutton says that thanks to its “easy yet elevated” design, this dress works for a variety of occasions. “No matter the print or colorway you choose, you’ll likely find yourself reaching for this piece on a regular basis. I’ve layered mine over long-sleeved shirts and added sparkly shoes for winter gatherings, and love to quickly throw it on with chunky slides for a casual summer day. It even works for the office! I also love that there are so many sizes to choose from — although if you have your eye on a specific shade, you’ll want to act quickly before it sells out!”

Anthropologie - The Colette Cropped Wide-Leg Pants by Maeve

“After renting these pants over and over again from Nuuly, I finally spent the $120 on a versatile black pair,” says Commerce Editor Samantha Sutton. “I like how they hug and support me in the waist and butt, but then become wider in the leg, allowing for movement and breathability. There are multiple colors and sizes to choose from — standard, tall, petite, plus, and even adaptive! I can’t rave about these bottoms enough.”

Blundstone All-Terrain Chelsea Boots

According to Executive Commerce Editor Tercius Bufete, Blundstone’s All-Terain Chelsea Boots had “no break-in period,” which is something that sets them apart. “They were instantly comfortable,” he says. “Equal parts handsome, well-made and water-resistant, these are the best boots I’ve ever owned. Bar none.”

Hoka Bondi 8

“The Hoka Bondi 8 Tennis Shoes make my walks and workouts more comfortable,” says Commerce Writer Olivia Hanson. “I love the massive color selection these sneakers come in and they’re stylish design as well.”

Cetaphil Daily Cleanser

“There are plenty of fancy cleansers out there and it may seem basic, but this $12 Cetaphil cleanser has never done me wrong,” says Commerce Writer Savannah Born. “My sister and I grew up using it and while we have very different skin types, we both swear by it! This fragrance-free cleanser got us through many years of turbulent teenage skin. Whether you have dry, oily or combination skin, this cleanser is effective and gentle enough for everyday use. The gel-like consistency feels luxurious!”

Farmacy Makeup Remover Cleansing Balm

“I’m all about finding efficient ways to get things done,” Commerce Writer Jasmine Washington says. “This cleansing balm removes stubborn makeup (waterproof liner and SPF included) without making my sensitive eyes water. That’s a plus in my book."

Sunday Riley CEO Glow Vitamin C Turmeric Face Oil

“Vitamin C has been a miracle ingredient for my skin, leaving it glowing, refreshed and blemish-free,” Commerce Editor Samantha Sutton notes. “With just a small drop, this oil will cover and moisturize your whole face, so a small bottle lasts for a long time.”

Sunday Riley Good Genes Lactic Acid Treatment

“Never have I seen my skin transform as much as it has with the Sunday Riley Good Genes Lactic Acid Face Serum,” Commerce Writer Olivia Hanson reveals. “I notice my skin looking tighter, more bright and clear and more plump as well after using it.”

Peter Thomas Roth Instant Firmx Eye Tightener

"I've tested somewhere between 20 and 30 under eye creams to banish discoloration and puffiness, but none have left me nearly as impressed as this Peter Thomas Roth pick," says Commerce Editor Madi Koetting. "It's a bit more heavy duty than a traditional eye cream, but it gets the job done. In just five minutes, puffiness and discoloration around the eye appears to have vanished. This is the only eye cream I use when I have an event or special occasion coming up — or when I look particularly puffy in the morning."

Hero Mighty Patch Pimple Patches

“Whenever I’m panicking about a pimple, I reach for a Mighty Patch and wear it overnight,” Commerce Editor Samantha Sutton says. “These hydrocolloid stickers quickly absorb all the gunk lying under your skin, shrinking the size of your blemish in hours rather than days. I’ve used both smaller and larger versions of these patches, but the OG always fits just right.”

Supergoop! Unseen Sunscreen

“White cast where? There’s none to be seen with the Supergoop! Unseen Sunscreen. ” says Commerce Writer Olivia Hanson. “Thanks to the clear matte formula, you literally can’t tell it’s there. It works great under makeup and still protects your skin with an SPF of 40.”

Supergoop! Glow Screen

“If anyone ever asks me for tinted sunscreen recommendations, my first instinctual thought is the Supergoop! Glow Screen,” admits Commerce Writer Olivia Hanson. “It acts as a tinted glowy filter on no-makeup days while still protecting my skin from the sun, and goes on flawlessly, acting as a luminous filter whenever doing a full makeup routine. I’m also committed to keeping my skin healthy and young-looking, so I appreciate the SPF 40 as well.”

innBeauty Project Extreme Cream

“If your current moisturizer isn’t cutting it for you, I definitely recommend trying the innBeauty Project Extreme Cream,” says Commerce Writer Olivia Hanson. “An editor-loved product, I’ve tested out this moisturizer for several months at this point and now feel like I can’t live without it. On top of plumping up my skin with moisturizing ingredients like peptides and ceramides, the glowy formula leaves my skin looking pearlescent. Though it’s $48, the 1.7 ounce bottle really lasts, so I definitely think it’s a great buy for the money.”

Fig Retinol Night Cream Level 1

“Retinol is an absolute must in your nighttime skincare routine! Not only does it gently exfoliate and unclog pores, but it increases collagen production, smoothes fine lines and evens skin tone — it’s like magic! ” Commerce Writer Savannah Born says. “The only issue is that it can irritate the skin, but this gentle retinol cream is designed to provide the same benefits without any irritation. Fig.1’s formula uses time-release technology to prevent sensitivity, ideal for those with dry, sensitive or acne-prone skin. The cream itself is thick and hydrating without leaving a greasy residue. It’s an everyday staple in my routine!”

Estée Lauder Advanced Night Repair Serum

“Elizabeth Hurley, Demi Moore and Cate Blanchett are just three of many celebs that use this nourishing serum. If it was good enough to help repair their skin overnight, I knew I had to try it," Commerce Writer Jasmine Washington says. "It combats the effects of UV light exposure and fights to speed up cell renewal to deliver refreshed skin."

Laneige Lip Sleeping Mask

“If there’s one beauty rule I’ve adhered to from childhood to adulthood is never to walk out of the house with dry, cracked lips,” Commerce Writer Jasmine Washington shares. “This Sydney Sweeney-loved mask keeps my lips nice and supple without making them stick together.”

Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm

“Regardless of the season, I always have a tube of this lip balm on hand,” admits Commerce Writer Taylor Lane. “It's intensely hydrating and tastes like dessert.”

Beauty by Earth Self Tanner

“I’ve tried sprays, mists and serums, but this organic formula is the only one that doesn’t leave behind patches, weird discoloration or irritation,” says Commerce Writer Savannah Born.

ILIA True Skin Serum Foundation

“I have been a fan of ILIA products for years, and this True Skin foundation is the best of the best,” says Commerce Editor Samantha Sutton. “Not only does it provide enough coverage to disguise any redness or tired eyes, but unlike similar options, it doesn’t include toxic chemicals.”

Kosas Revealer Concealer

“I’d been using my previous concealer for about four years before I tried the Kourtney Kardashian-loved Revealer Concealer, which turned me into a Kosas convert!" says Commerce Writer Olivia Hanson. "I have a lot of things that need fixing when it comes to concealer, such as under eye bags, redness and blemishes, and this one covers them ever-so-flawlessly. It has a medium coverage, so I can keep my concealing as subtle as I want, but it’s also buildable for days I need extra coverage. The doe foot applicator makes it easy to apply and it usually lasts me for several weeks before I need a refill.” 

L’Oreal Infallible 3-Second Setting Spray

“It’s no secret that I’m a notoriously sweaty gal who loves wearing layers of makeup almost every day,” jokes Commerce Writer Jasmine Washington. “That combination requires a fool-proof beauty routine packed with a setting spray that won’t budge. After seeing how flawless Olympic gymnast Suni Lee’s makeup looked after her routines during the Summer Olympics, I couldn’t wait to try out the setting spray she used. This drug-store find deserves a medal of its own for always keeping my face nice and matte.”

They’re Real Mascara by Benefit Cosmetics

“I have naturally long eyelashes, but this mascara takes them from zero to hero,” says Commerce Writer Savannah Born. “It’s on the pricey side for mascara, so I don’t want to like it, but I keep coming back.”

Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Liquid Blush

“This is hands down the most pigmented blush I’ve ever worn,” says Commerce Editor Madi Koetting. “Every little detail, from the elegant bottle design to the range of hues, is unbeatable. One bottle has lasted me nearly two years, and I wear this almost every single day. I prefer to blend it on my cheekbones with a makeup brush, but it also blends beautifully with just my fingers.”

Shark FlexStyle Hair Drying System

“As a curly-haired girl, I’ve yet to find a hair styling system that doesn’t yank my strands out with every swipe,” says Commerce Editor Madi Koetting. “It comes with five styling attachments for a salon-worthy blowout, and the under $300 price point makes it a slightly more affordable choice than popular options that mimic the same quality of this system. I’ve owned my Shark FlexStyle since it launched in 2022 and feel confident knowing this is the only hair drying system I’ll ever need.”

Olaplex Bond Maintenance Shampoo and Conditioner

“As a beauty writer, I've tested out tons of different shampoos, but nothing makes my hair feel as good as the Olaplex No. 4 Bond Maintenance Shampoo. Trust me, I've tried! After each use, it feels stronger, healthier and smoother than before, just as if I came out of a salon appointment,” says Commerce Writer Olivia Hanson.

PATTERN by Tracee Ellis Ross Strong Hold Hair Gel

“Curlfriends, we’ve got a hit on our hands,” says Commerce Writer Jasmine Washington. “Whether you're slicking your mane into a sleek bun or rocking a wash-and-go, this nourishing gel delivers long-lasting hold without leaving behind flakes or the crunchy texture we despise. Along with smoothing hair, it's enriched with aloe vera, chia seeds and sea moss to nourish your strands! Not to mention it’s from Tracee Ellis Ross’ brand. Her voluminous curls are proof of how well it works.”

amika Supernova Moisture & Shine Cream

“I use this cream both on damp and dry hair,” says Commerce Editor Samantha Sutton. “When I want a sleeker airdried look, I’ll apply it shortly after getting out of the shower, or rake it through my strands before blowdrying for some extra shine. It’s also my go-to product when taming flyaways and frizz — all it takes is a drop to work its magic and it’s lightweight enough that it doesn’t leave behind a greasy look.”

Nutrafol Hair Growth Supplement

"I have a naturally fine hairline, but after years of high-tension hairstyles I've experienced severe breakage. After using Nutrafol for almost two months, I've noticed significant changes," says Commerce Writer Jasmine Washington. "I've raved to my all my friends and family, and even convinced one of my guy friends to try out their new men's version."

Kiss Impress Press-On Nails

“As a girl who’s always on the go, there’s nothing more convenient than being able to apply press-on nails while ripping and running around New York City,” Commerce Writer, Jasmine Washington says. “Kiss imPRESS has so many cool press-on nail collabs with brands like Kate Spade and Arizona. Best of all? Even if I apply these falsies while I’m on the subway, I can get them to last for almost two weeks.”

Olive & June

“I used to be dedicated to my twice monthly salon manicures, but once I discovered Olive & June’s long-lasting polish, I haven’t been back to the nail salon,” says Commerce Editor Madi Koetting. “Their polish comes in two formulas, long lasting and quick dry. Every color I’ve tested, from light pinks to bold blues, goes on smooth and streak-free. The cherry on top is Olive & June’s 15-free ingredient list — the brand’s guarantee that their polish is free of 15 different “no-no” ingredients. This is the only polish I feel good about wearing thanks to their safe and long lasting finish. My at-home manicures last more than 10 days!”

Smithey Cast Iron Skillet

“The quality and aesthetic of Smithey Ironworks pans make them heirloom-level,” says Executive Commerce Editor Tercius Bufete. “In fact, I’ve steadily collected these pans over the course of a few years and its latest pan, the Little Farmhouse Skillet, is their most affordable carbon steel pan yet. It’s my designated egg pan and its use is my favorite part of my breakfast routine. It gets better and better with use, and that’s a rarity in most things nowadays.”

Our Place Always Pan

Beloved by Selena Gomez, Cameron Diaz and Paris Hilton, there’s a reason why the Our Place Always Pan is taking over everyone’s kitchen. “It cooks food all the way through, is extremely durable and looks aesthetic on my stove,” says Commerce Writer Olivia Hanson.

Beautiful by Drew Barrymore Air Fryer

“An air fryer is a fairly hefty kitchen appliance, and it’s important to pick one that’s equally stylish as it is powerful. The Beautiful by Drew Barrymore Air Fryer sits pretty on the counter while crisping everything from french fries to brussels sprouts to perfection," says Commerce Editor Madi Koetting. "No food is off limits — I roast chicken tenders, air fry potatoes and reheat leftovers with this beauty. This air fryer was my entry into the Beautiful by Drew Barrymore kitchen line, and now I own three of the brand’s appliances.”

Nespresso Vertuo Plus

“It took me months to ditch Starbucks (I still struggle), but this at-home coffee maker does help make delicious drinks when I need to pick me up,” says Commerce Writer Taylor Lane.

Vitamix Explorian Blender

“As an avid foodie and home cook, I strongly believe you get what you pay for when it comes to blenders,” says Commerce Editor Madi Koetting. “I’ve spent anywhere between $50 and $200 trying to find the best blender, but nothing compares to the Vitamix Explorian Blender. This brand is the creme de la creme of blenders, and their worth every. single. Penny. The Explorian model is a middle of the line price point for Vitamix blenders. You’ll be amazed at how fast this work horse of a kitchen appliance blends roasted veggies into creamy soups.”