Gabby Windey revealed the “craziest interaction” she’s had with another star — and it involved her wife, comedian Robby Hoffman.
Windey, 35, opened up about an unexpected encounter she had with a fellow reality star during a recent episode of First We Feast. When challenged to answer a juicy question or eat a spicy wing, Windey agreed to “reveal the craziest interaction [she’s] had with a fellow reality TV member and [to] name names.”
“You bet your ass I will because I’m not eating that other chicken,” the former Bachelorette replied. “Heather Gay from Real Housewives of Salt Lake City did say that she would f*** my wife.”
Windey continued, “I don’t know if she remembers, but I do. We are very monogamous, Heather. And she only has eyes for me.”
@firstwefeast avoiding the wings at all cost 😭 #truthordabrapidfire
Windey then joked that she would have answered “anything” to avoid eating a spicy wing.
“I need a Prilosec. How come you don’t have those aid out on the table?” she quipped.
“Avoiding the wings at all cost 😭,” the official First We Feast account captioned the post. Fans shared their reactions in the comments section.
“I wasn’t expecting this good of tea,” one wrote, while another added, “I love it 👏👏👏.”
Windey first revealed that she was dating a woman via Instagram in August 2023.
“It’s hard to get it out all right now but I know everyone’s been really curious about who I’m dating,” she said. “You know I love to stir the pot and tease, but I did want to wait until I was ready, because it is a larger conversation — because I’m dating a girl.”
She then revealed that her mystery woman was Hoffman, 36. “[I’m] in a relationship like I feel like I’ve never had before,” she added. “But I wanted to tell you guys because I always just want to live my life honestly and have you all along with me.”
Windey later revealed in April 2025 that she legally tied the knot with Hoffman following their Las Vegas ceremony in January.
“I do thee legally wed!!” Windey captioned a number of pics of her and Hoffman. For their ceremony, the Traitors winner rocked a semi-sheer dress featuring a fitted top and voluminous ruffled skirt. She accessorized with a veil and hoop earrings. Hoffman, for her part, looked chic in a white tee, a dress shirt and black shades.
